|
Project KEEP US Knowledge Enabling Efforts to Preserve University Students __________________________________________________________________ |
|
Findings: Q 28 |
| Return to "Findings" home page (For more information, go to www.projectkeepus.com) |
Q 28. Enter here any other comments you would like to see included in this study:
$500 is appropriate, thanks.
A clear delineation for graduate students. Being in graduate school and
finishing is very differnt from finishing undergraduate studies.
A wider base of major's of the colleges.
A wider range of occupations, more specific in town and county location rather
than areas. I live on the border of Franklin County so could work there and
still be close to where I live.
about international students' life
About the availability of jobs, or how kids can find out about them.
add questions about what you think of the city of syracuse
Additionally, I don't think the city of Syracuse is a safe area. Surrounding
suburbs can be marketed as small communities that would be ideal for families,
but not only is the city of Syracuse drab for young people, it is also unsafe.
advertise more
after living abroad for 3 months, it is hard to acclimate back to the american
society. i would prefer to live in an area that is less developed and on or near
the ocean.
Again I think you covered quite a bit of information needed for your survey,
Thanks for allowing me to participate.
alot of words very subjective - "soon", "really", etc.
Always be yourself
An ARCHITECTURE option for a major, or type of INDUSTRY. No worries, we are
always forgotten about in surveys.
Answering the question about whether I plan to immediately start a family was
tough considering that I have been married for many years and have a teenage
daughter. Perhaps more options to account for those of us who aren't "young and
hip"?
As a sociology major, I find your sampling methods to be non-representative.
Your survey is also biased towards a positive view of CNY. Lastly, your options
in a variety of sections aren't mutually exclusive or exhaustive.
As a student, I don't feel that there is much interaction between the university
and the surrounding community. I feel that this is a wasted opportunity. There
are various activities agoing on in Syracuse and the surrounding areas that many
students could benefit from and enjoy. The university could also be giving back
to the community. I'm not sure what's
the best way to remedy this, but I think there is certainly room for improvement
As an international student I can't say much... Mostly I'll be returning to my
home country to apply the knowledge I obtained in the manufacturing feild
As far as my personal needs are concerned in the area of residence and career, I
am not at all convinced that they can be met in northern New York.
As I mentioned, I'm planning on getting a series of 3-6 month internships over
the next few years before going back to grad school and then eventually settling
down somewhere, which influenced my choices on the earlier "likelyhood to live
here after graduation" questions.
As of now, I will most likely reside in the New York City area after graduation.
As the area has stagnated over the past 25 years so have the available options
for students to explore with internships while in school and employment post
graduation. Since manufacturing is on the ebb perhaps a concertive effort could
be made to utilize the well educated population by attracting research and
technology inovators to the area. Without
viable options graduates will emigrate to areas presenting these options.
Ask me what I hate most about this area! (It's the weather/grey skies!!)
Backrounds from which people came. Ex...someone born and raised in the back
woods of Redfield would have different opinions about say moving to a city like
Syracuse.
Be aware that not all students are 18-22 years old!
Be more open minded, one of the survey's had almost every question pertaining to
CNY. Ask random questions, find out more about what a student would like to be
doing, instead of hinting at where you think they should go. More open ended
questions, less survey questions. And also, don't have little extra questions if
someone clicks "other" or
something, it makes you feel like an idiot for doing it, have those for every
answer, just see what a student will say. If i'm an enviromental major, that's
all you know, if i fill out where my specialty in that department will be, then
there you have it, you know about that person too, not just the person that
planned on doing design research for QUAL
Be more to the point, don't make us answer the same question basically multiple
times.
Better communication and understanding of students. As a student I have had a
really tough time with staff at the college involving financial aid and other
services. People need to stop and realize that some of us are doing this on our
own for the first time and it is scary and confusing. Faculty needs to realize
we do not necessarily know what is going on
and we need help.
better questions, not so confusing
Broaden the fields or give an area for a fill-in-the-blank for individuals to
maybe write down a field that is not listed instead of "other". The Survey is
good for whatever u are trying to attain as a research question, but i feel as
though there are a few forced area of questioning.
Central New York is more or less a boring area because of its sparse nature,
however it has much to offer in terms of entertainment that is over an hour's
drive away. I feel that colleges comprise much of the culture in the area, but
it is difficult to imagine much more interesting things in the area than
education.
central NY is a very ncie part of the country, however the industry I would like
ot go into requires a much lrger city
Certain career choices, such as mine, are fairly inflexible when it comes to
where someone will actually live. If Syracuse was the center of the theatre
world, I'd live here, but it's not, so I'm not going to live here. ...Also I
think you should include more background info besides race- perhaps parent's
income, types of schools attended b4 current one etc.
Clean up the city! Crime is a huge issue and a large reason for why people do
not settle in the city of Syracuse
CNY is a depressed region and it's moving backwards. Y'all need to cut out the
unions and let some of the tech stuff that's going on down south flow in here.
Also, up the education level of the average resident, and maybe you'll have less
brain-drain. If everyone isn't trying to parlay two $25,000 salaries into
driving two honkin' big SUVs, there might be
some savings and a bit of a cultural/artistic community could develop.
College students that live in the area they go to school are the most likely to
stay. In order to keep the students from outside the area, there needs to be
more of a young community, and some night life.
Comments like "near" are very general. Living "near" my parents means on the
same coast to me, but to others it might mean the same street.
comments on the surrounding town or village that we must suffer through aka
Hamilton village that is only a street long which really sucks
Companies should come to speak to the college communities.
Create better transport links. A ZipCar service would be ideal (cars parked
around the city available for short term trips (eg for shopping, to the mall, to
the lakes, to the surrounding areas (finger lakes etc)). Lots of graduate
students never see anything of the area because they can't afford a car and
can't afford to rent one ... Seriously there are many
graduate students that have never been to Skinneatlas or any of the finger lakes
...
criimail justice
Crime is a big problem in Syracuse, and I think it does effect my decision to
leave the area.
DESCRIBE WHY THE NOIRTH COUNTRY SUCKS
Do something about the ramapant crime and strong arm robberies in the SU area!
Improve the K-12 education without taxing the homeowners to death! That mall
will not be the saving grace of CNY! All it will do is route commerce away from
small mom-and pop bussinesses, and make a handfull of investors wealthy. Find
someother way to revitalize
NY! Good lord, follow New Hampshire and make racing legal! "I Love NY" should
read "I love high taxes" "I love low wages" "I love high crime rates" "I love
barely survivable winters" The winters cannot be fixed, but the state of NY must
do something about the other three issues!
do you plan to work or continue your education after completing your current
schooling?
don't have all enough majors mentioned, or space for double-majors
Don't have any
economical issues. taxes......
End the war on drugs, and I'll stay in NYS.
Entertainment
ESF is a great school in a horrible city
Everyone wants to leave Syracuse. The weather is terrible, the city is sub-par
in terms of jobs, and anything to do...so close to NYC that it is impossible to
compete with cities like that and like Boston, etc where "all the good jobs" and
excitement are...being young, we wanna experience these things...Syracuse is
more of a place to settle down--NOT a
place one would dream of starting off a career. Once you are married and tied
down with kids, Syracuse and surrounding cities seem a viable option. However,
Massachusetts is a much better state(my homestate) :) so I would rather raise a
family/settle somewhere there. Sorry, NY but I do not love you...NYC, however--I
do, I do, and...here I co
Everything is good, and nice....
Everything is good, and nice....
Excellent school. I had a few issues when registering for classes. The school
tends to send students on a run around and does very little preventative
maintenance to prevent problems. I still have a couple of unresolve issues and
I'm SUPPOSE to graduate in December 2004.
expand transportation system
Explain some of the questions better, like, 1-10 questions
final results of survey should be notified
Fix the education system so people can excel @ their own pace without being
restricted by time or beaurocratic restraints.
For certain professions, there are locations that you are expected to go to, and
don't have much of a choice. For instance, I chose Syracuse University because
of its excellent Musical Theatre program, because I need the training, not
because I wanted to live in Upstate New York (which I dislike).
For the country ot publish a book with each state to have its own capsule and
show all the stuff in there state and attractions
Gear some of the questions to people who commute and transfer in to the college.
Good Luck
Great study... Goodluck
hands on experience and show students what really goes on in those career areas
have a not applicable or N/A column when asking specific questions.
Have fun in college!
Hopefully the area adds more entertainment or industries in order to increase
the populaton.
how about, "Do you LIKE the syracuse area?"
How do you feel you have been treated as a student by the community outside the
university? Why will you/will you not stay in the area?
How does the current environement work for or against your desire to live and or
work in that environment. I feel that the current political and other systems in
place do not allow for stability, job growth, job security, etc. This in turn
makes people feel uncertain about their future in that area and start
considering moving to another area where jobs are
encouraged to grow. I have heard that jobs used to flourish in Upstate New York,
but I have not seen any of that sort of thing.
How helpful the career service room is... I find that they don't know enough
about other options and can't guide with what the demand is.
How many people commented on the cost of living for new york state and it
outrageous taxes
how many people move to the Syracuse area for education alone
How the impact of family/home life/growing up has attributed to the decisions
made as to what courses of study students choose to pursue and why.
how was your education funded?
How well are you doing in your course of study?
How well do you know the area in which you are going to school? Alot of students
don't know what the area has to offer.
How well the institution I attend is meeting my needs
I absolutely love living here in upstate New York. It's a beautiful area that
still has a lot of open space, which is very important to me. It's a refreshing
change from my hometown, where all the remaining farmland is being bought up and
developed. There is a different mentality regarding what is "close" or "nearby"
than there is at home, but I'm willing to
make that mental adjustment. I am definitely going to return to upstate New York
at some point in my life. I'd love to retire here and just enjoy what the small
communities and the open areas have to offer.
i am attracted to areas that have many idependant businesses, family owned
stuff. they suggest to me that this is a community that looks after its own and
is concerned about the members that are a part of it. retail chain stores
suggest to me people trying to get cash and unconcerned with identity or
community.
I am from a small town. I do not go any further past my college into Utica
because I am not familair with it and am afraid of getting lost.
I am interested in knowing the results.
I am not sure that I saw anything about whether the area I plan to locate in
after graduation is conducive to my recreational needs also, such as water
sports, and outdoor activities.
I am probably not the ideal candidate for this survey. I am already established
in the area. By the way, Syracuse is not my "hometown". I choose to stay in the
area, after attending Syracuse University as an undergraduate. Syracuse has bad
weather, bad taxes,(as is NY state) pretty bad job opportunites, but excellent
educational opportunities, and many
excellent medical facilities. It is a fine place to raise a family.
I am what the college calls a "non-traditional" student. Most of the students in
my class are young enough to be my children. I initially found the college
experience very intimidating however CCC and their staff have made my experience
enjoyable as well as exciting. The staff have all been extremely helpful and I
found them to be very encouraging as I
move ahead on my journey to teaching.
I appreciate what you are trying to do, this area is beautiful and has a lot to
offer. Unfortunately it is very hard to find jobs around here and I personally,
have to go where I will earn enough to live comfortably and pay back loans.
I can't think of anything
i change my mind everyday about what i would do the next day, so this is not
really useful.
I currently live in Rochester and commute to Syracuse for classes or take
classes on-line. I hadn't planned on moving after graduation unless I was
offered a dream job.
I definitely don't think that age and gender should be in there.
I do feel upstate new york has been left out. Everyone wonders why businesses
leave and factories shut down, its because there is no incentive for
students/new grads to stay. I am back in Syr to do my graduate degree (i'm from
Syracuse originally), and there's just not a lot offered, and I think thats a
pity. Someone needs to look at whats going out
(politicans and such) and really evaluate our current state of affairs. and I
vote, so i can say that!
I do not consider the great Syracuse area to be a very hip place to live right
after college..and certainly not a place that I see living with my friends right
after graduation. Most of us seem to want to go to larger cities such as Boston,
New York City, Washington D.C., San Francisco, Chicago and Seattle.
I don't believe I can find anything up here that will be in my field of study
I don't exactly have one particular dream job, because I want to have several
careers over the course of my life, such as joining the military, becoming a
lawyer, and then working for the government, that question should be added to
the study b/c not everyone wants to live in one place forever or have one dream
job.
I don't really have much choice about staying here. If I want to work at a
university, chances are I will have little choice in it's location, other than
what multi-state region (e.g. New England, Mid-Atlantic) it is located in.
i don't really like NY much at all. there is no reason for me to live here.
I don't think that most people usually end up staying in the city that they went
to college, especially cities of this size (Syracuse) or smaller where the job
fields are limited. I also think the idea of living near family is also pretty
appealing to grads these days: it will be interesting to see what your survey
says about this.
I enjoy college a lot never thought I would have this much fun studing children
and their behavior
I enjoyed this survey. It got me really thinking about post-college life.
I feel strongly that public transportation would be a good selling point to
graduating students if marketed correctly
I generally do not like the weather.
I grew up in a few different places around the country so you should maybe ask
more questions about the background of cities.
I had a hard time including in my answers that while I would like to be near my
family it hasn't factored into my job decision b/c it isn't really a possibility
in the peace corps and I know that is where I want to be. family for me would be
much more i
i had an unbelievable experience at colgate but i'm definitely looking to be
closer to either new york city or boston.
I hate the weather. I am from Nevada, and the weather here is the most horrible
thing i hav ever experienced. Since I know how great the West is in terms of
weather i would never settle down and subject myself to such a cruel
environment.
I have found that there is not a good way of finding jobs in the area. At the
job fairs I have attended the representatives and not very interested in talking
with students, and they are not up to date on what job are avaiable in their
company.
i have lived in a busy area my whole life and am perfectly happy being out here
in the middle of nowhere for now!
I have lived in this area for years now, and I go to places such as Rochester,
Troy, Ithaca and even Buffalo to attend cultural events, use libraries or do
other things. It is apparent to me, that the public transport system is not laid
out for me to do this. If I attend a cultural event in Rochester that ends at
midnight, the first bus back to Syracuse leaves at 4 in
the morning (in the winter -- in the summer it's better). There is no bus
connection (or wasn't, when I acquired about two years ago) to Ithaca that would
allow me to go there in the morning and return in the evening. On several
streets in and around Syracuse, car drivers shout "go on the sidewalk" or "it's
illegal to bike her
I hope my answers to the survey questions are helpful to you in every way
i like it that diffrent industries come to the school and tell us what they have
to offer.
I like Syracuse, but it has disavantages: street shootings and the weather.
I like the direction of this survey! a good map w/ info on events available more
positive press in local papers- many events get little pre or post coverage'
connect the colleges to each other w/ shared events could be done easily through
existing publications on each campus! more ads to college students to inform
them of the many cultural events going
on in downtown connect cultural events w/ college cultural events- perhaps some
of our International studnets would like to be available to participate in these
events, not just partake!
I like the Syracuse area and I see it is a town that is just begining to realize
it's potential in the service industry. The transition from manufacturing to
service industries is jsut starting to mature and I think there will be a lot of
opportunity growing in the Syracuse area. I would be willing to stay if I did
not have prior obligations, and I may return someday.
I live near Rochester, in Livingston County, which is next to Monroe county.
These counties are in upstate NY, but were not mentioned in the part of the
survey asking about where we live, or would like to work.
i love alf
I LOVE SYRACUSE, BUT THEY NEED TO CLEAN THE CITY UP AND BRING MORE COMPANIES
INTO THE CITYAND LOWER THE TAXES.
I love Syracuse, I've lived here my entire life. It just isn't big enough and it
doesn't provide the opportunities for a career in my field.
I love this area because of the ability to live in more rural areas with a lot
of land and a beautiful sienic environment, while still being ten to twenty
minutes away from everything in the city.
I moved to Syracuse from Los Angeles, CA and I knew that I could not compare
this city to my hometown. What I expected (in the least) was somewhat akin to
Ithaca or Rochester. Both of these cities offer more opportunities for young
people. Additionally, there is a HUGE gap between the Syracuse community and the
college community. There should
be more services and organizations that reach out to the community to bridge
this gap.
I myself do not factor in "young and hip' when i think of where i ideally would
like to live.
I never reall thought about where I wanted to live after college. I really think
it is just going to be where I can get a job.
I noticed many of the questions are geared towards yound college students, maybe
those who have graduated highschool and are at their first year of school. Maybe
if there could be more questions regarding adult students, like myself, who are
single parents raising children, or just an adult who has started school again
and hasn't been in for 15-20
years. Other than that i felt this is a very positive questionaire and i was
happy to be a part of it-thanks.
I noticed that many of the statements in this study seemed to reflect the
traditional college student's way of life and thinking. I am a non-traditional
student attending Cayuga CC. I'm not sure if the Fulton community is actually
aware how many non-traditional students attend their campus in Fulton, NY. I
work with more non-trads and the numbers seem
to be rising. The traditional students seem to be the minority at Cayuga. Way to
go CCC in Fulton!!
I personally believe that financial security and job availability will be major
factors in determining where graduates locate after finishing their education.
Although larger cities do not appeal to me at this time, I may reconsider based
upon WHERE I can get a job, as oppossed to where I'd prefer to locate.
I plan on going to graduate school in Calif. when I am done with my BA, and I
would eventually like to live overseas, possibly England.
i probably don't know much about the area and am not particularly focused about
my post-graduation plans because it is my first year at SU as a freshman.
I really have no idea about what is locally offered here for post-grads - the
only jobs I know about are those on my present college campus
I simply would never live here after graudation because of the winters.
I think all suggestions should be forwarded to the community they are coming
from
I think having a family is something that has been kind of over looked but more
than that this is really geared towards traditional students, I do not really
fit that category. I went to college right out of high school for 2.5 years then
got married put my husband through college, had two kids and only then could I
try to go back to school, and when I did the
classes I took originally in 1993 were pretty much worthless and my idea about
what I wanted to be had changed. I think more and more "older" people are going
back to get their degrees and I do not think that was addressed in this survey
I think it covered all bases
I think it is essential that the taxes in this area are lowered.. Between NiMo
and taxes, it is nearly impossible for a young family to meet their needs. We
are therefore continuously losing the best and brightest to warmer and more
tax-friendly locales.
I think it is hard to find CAZENOVIA ON A MAP, i PERSONALLY STUMBLED ACROSS THE
COLLEGE, BUT FELL IN LOVE WITH IT ONCE I KNEW IT WAS HERE....MAKE THE AREA MORE
WELL KNOWN AT A BROADER SPECTRUM
I think it is pretty much comprehensive.
I think it was pretty inclusive.
I think it's great that someone does research like this to get ideas of the
students of this area. I think that this area could offer a lot more to younger
people/students and with this survey maybe something could be done.
I think many outsiders see central New Yorkers as being negative. There is
endless complaining about the weather, the football coach, taxes, and the
government. Is it any wonder? The news media does little to alleviate this
cancer – I worked in it for several years, so I know this all too well.
Furthermore, get the community to understand low-skilled high-
paying manufacturing jobs are a thing of the past. Stop acting like the world is
ending when these jobs are outsourced. An important fundamental of economics is
that "trade makes everyone better off." This trend will continue. Learn from the
past, but look to the future. I've lived in CNY my whole life and life is not as
dismal as it's reputa
I think that Colgate's Career Services connects students to people outside of
the area... I don't think that Colgate sends students into the area.
i think that hamilton was a great place to go to school and i enjoyed the
outdoor activities that central New York provides but there are areas in the
north east whose weather is not as depressing.
i think that salaries are the only thing that are not keeping the people up in
the north country. why live up in st. lawrence county..or anywhere above new
york city when i could move and make so much more money.
I think that the biggest problem with keeping kids is that there isn't a lot for
underage kids to do. For instance, as a 19 yr. old wo will finish her education
when she is 20, there isn't much for me to do on a Friday or Saturday night. I
think that's why some kids leave so early, because there's not much to do.
I think that the questions regarding the proximity to family as a factor in
deciding where one wants to live should be looked at separately from wanting to
live in the area where one grew up. I want to live in the area where I grew up,
which happens to be where my family lives, because of the resources, not because
that is where my family lives. I would
want to live there because I already know that it has more physicians than any
other city in the country, and the best hospitals, museums, theatres,
restaurants, and everything else that I would want or need. I also think that
where one is accepted to graduate school, and what schools have the most
appropriate programs, as a factor affecting
I think that this was a great idea, because it really shows what is wanted by
the students of colleges and those who have been in college for a few years or
are coming back to college as a person with a family!
i think that's about it
I think the CNY area is having a hard time retaining and attracting college
grads due to the businesses that are leaving the area. This area has lots of
service jobs paying minimum wage but good paying jobs in specialized fields are
very slim in the CNY area.
I think the non-traditonal student should be taken into account.
I think the study should include a section of the reasons why many of the area's
college students don't stay in the area after graduating.
I think there needs to be more of an effort to get students out to the city of
Syracuse and show them what it would be like to live there rather than keeping
us on campus so much. Its hard to convince someone to live somewhere that they
have never really seen or been connected to.
I think there should be a question asking students how well this survey actually
judges anything. Ya know, I don't think (personally) the emphasis on young/hip
communities is as important to a graduate as it is to a student.
I think there's more here than people realize, including myself. I've lived in
the North Country my entire life and I'm just learning that there are in fact
opportunities for technical people in this area. They just don't seem to be
publicized for whatever reason.
I think this actually was a well-structured study.
I think this study is rather biased. I am not offended, but why would you first
specifically ask if the interviewy is hispanic and then ask the general racial
question?
I think this study was a very helpful one.
i think this study was good, and i hope it helps
i think this survey provided a good realm of questions, good luck in your study!
I think this survey should have a print out because it had a lot of good
information that one should consider when planning for after college. it'd be a
useful tool to help decide on the best location
I think you should ask more about the types of housing/living arrangements.
While jobs and career choices are important, what the housing infrastructure is
like is just as important. I have found that there is an absensce of new housing
in the entry level buyer market. Or maybe there is and I just have never been
made aware of it.
I thought it was very thorough. As a guest to NYS, I think the biggest obstacle
for CNY and upstate NY are the taxes and more specifically the tax allocation.
80% of all taxes should stay local with the remaining 20% going to support the
greater state because the current condition is outrageous.
I thought that this survey was very good in asking the correct questions etc.
I thought the questions were well thought out, though it wasn't geared toward
anyone who is a fresh or sop. in school b/c most of them don't know what they
want to do yet
I was confused with questions about family. I live with my family (husband and
four teenage kids). I do not live with or want to live near my family (parents
or brother). If I can earn enough money to support my family, pay off my student
loans, and further my career, staying in Central NY is my preference - at least
until my youngest graduates from high
school in 2011. If I get a solid job offer or post-doc that will further my
career and provide financial security, than my family will move.
i wash there were more job opportunites up here in the north country. It has a
lot of potential to succeed if there were more .
I will be moving away because of the weather? can you research how to change the
weather?
I will have many loans when I finish my degree
I would consider my spouse to be my family not my parents though that is not how
i answered the questions since that is not how you wrote it. I expect to move to
where ever both my spouse and I both can agree on and where we both have
employment or graduate school. You didn't ask about grad school.
I would get off campus more often if I had the time to.
i would like an email of the results
I would like to know if there is any information out there right now on
incentives for college students to settle in this area.
I would like to see questions for the non-traditional students, like me. I am
already married, have a child, own a house, but my house is not near my
hometown. Therefore, I had a hard time answering questions pertaining to
"family" because I knew you were referring to parents, siblings, etc., but the
family that most influences my decisions about where
to live are my husband and my son.
I would like to see Syracuse target young people and get them involved in
cultural activities by giving student discounts to operas, museums, etc. Make
the area more student-friendly.
I would like to see Syracuse with a lot more cultural events, and more diverse
places to go on the weekend.
I would like to see the majors and minors less categorized so we can see where
people end up based on specific majors and specific programs. The results could
be published in the undergraduate manual and give undecided students a bit more
guidance and information on the views of those in certain programs. Regardless,
I think this is a very valuable
survey and should definitely be taken to city government. Syracuse NEEDS to
retain SU grads and other highly educated and intelligent individuals to fill
positions throughout the city.
Ich will ein berlinda
id like to see more internship opportunities
I'd like to see what graduates think they'll do if their ideal situation doesn't
work out.
Ideas for how to keep students in the area.
If i knew more about the area perhaps my choices on this study would be more
accurate or inflouenced
If I wasn't born and raised here, I would have no intention of staying here!
If Syracuse wants to keep young people, besides the ones who were born here and
have no ambition to leave, it hast to make itself attractive to students as soon
as they arrive.
If you're trying to get college grads to stay in the upstate region, you're
going to have to change the entire dynamic of campus social life. Here at
Syracuse, it's rare for people to venture beyond the university area. Job fairs
and area promotions can help, but in general, it's hard to change what people
have set in their minds as their plans for the future.
Sure, most of us are pretty unsure about what we want to do after we graduate,
but I think the prevailing trends are that we either move somewhere completely
foreign and exotic, or return to where we grew up. It does happen that people
fall in love with the city around the university, but that only happens when
they have reasons and
I'm a little worried about the repeated emphasis on "young and hip" as drawing
cards for college grads--since I am definitely not the former and probably not
the latter either, a community geared toward those that are would probably not
welcome me!
I'm from downstate and have seen some improvements in the Syracuse area over the
past few years but there is still a lot more that needs to be done. There are
too many abandoned buildings that could be used.
I'm leaving for graduate school post-bachelor's and one of the main factors is
the tyoe of city that I plan to attend school. In the survey there is no
response type for people planning to leave because of additional academic work.
I might consider returning to Syracuse, but the talk of DestiNY really turns me
off from the area. The local planning doesn't
seem to take into account the demographic of "northeast liberal elitists".
Syracuse is an area dominated by chain stores and strip malls. Very
unattractive. Take lessons from Madison, WI or DC's Gerogetown area, Boston,
North Carolina's research triangle, etc. If Armory/Hanover Square could be made
bigger and more attached to campus it
I'm not certain of any changes I would recommend, the study seemed to cover all
bases.
im not sure exactly the type of info you want. i assume you are trying to
attract business to the area. Ask more questions on the spectrum of knowledge
about work opportunities in the area.
I'm not sure how representative I am, in that I came to Syracuse to attend
college as an undergraduate and then DID settle here immediately upon
graduation. If my husband and I both found acceptable positions somewhere with
better weather, we'd consider moving, but we'd rather stay here if I can find
reasonable work. Thus, earlier in the survey, I
said some things were important, yet they don't exist here (such as lots of jobs
in my field). So I'm not sure my responses in that section are actually
providing the data you were looking for.
Importance of parks, outdoor recreation, open/green space planning
In addition, the manager at my local job refused to send me for additional
training even though it was an integral part of my position. I may sound like
I'm complaining excessively but it has truly been the most negative work
experience I have ever had.
in many grad programs, employers would need to work with the department heads to
arrange time for students to learn about local opportunities (maybe something on
campus designed for grad students?), I did not have time to explore the
building, let alone the area
In multiple selection options, include not applicable.
In order to get as much out of your education as you can, sometimes you have to
move to certain areas i.e. where things are happening in your field.
In the hypothetical places to live, don't include nearness to family on every
one, but instead include cultural, diversity, or tolerance factors.
include architecture
include entertainment industry as part of career choices. Yes it really does
exist and is a major part of the workfore outside of just general manufacturing
and serive jobs.
Include local area salaries and areas of potential future growth.
Include Middle-eastern as a race category.
Instead of always saying "the area", try being more specific about WHAT area as
"the area" gets very confusing when you're questioning on the area that we want
to live in when done with college as well as the area that our college is in.
Is crime a factor? should be asked.
It is a great city, but the WEATHER!! It is so bad and I am from upstate NY and
it is worse here!
It is really difficult to find help in searching for internships and jobs at
this school
It is so hard for Cazenovia College students to go beyond Cazenovia (or for any
Madison County residents for that matter). Some sort of reliable public
transportation would not only encourage students to learn more about the
surrounding area but would also further shopping in Syracuse.
It is very wordy
It may helpful to you not only to find out where students grew-up, but where
they did their undergrad if they are graduate students.
It might be helpful to have a not applicable choice at the beginning of the
questionarre. Also, one of the main reasons i would not live in the area I
attend school is because it is not safe. I would never want to raise my children
here. THere have been over 80 shootings in this city in 2004 thus far. A
question about why one wouldn't continue living where
they go to school would be some more relevant feedback.
It might want to ask, what does one feel about not being able to find a job
right away.
It seems to me that Syracuse, or Central NY in general has nothing but SU and
the mall (maybe you could include Armorie Square). If there are other things to
do around here, it needs to be announced somehow. Because the majority of
students dont know about them. I think if there was more culture here it would
attract more people: MUSIC,
CONCERTS (hiphop), theatre, speakers, etc.
It was pretty thorough.
It would be a lot more effective to put some money into the city so grads felt
like staying and putting in some effort wouldn't be such a lost cause. There
needs to be some incentive to stay ... more job opportunities, a more vibrant
city life. Investing in the education and life opportunities of Syracuse
citizens would also be a lot more effective in building this
city. It doesn't matter how many able-bodied and intelligent college graduates
are retained if there are masses of ill-educated and poor citizens struggling to
make a living. The two will not balance each other.
It's a really nice place here, but I miss home a lot. I don't hate the area and
I'll come back to visit, but my heart is at home and I'm going to go back there
when I'm done here.
its good
It's good!
It's long
It's not that I don't like the Syracuse area, it's just that I like the Boston
area better and I'm more familiar with it.
I've made the decision that my professional life will be tied to that of my
partner's. While he is studying for a Ph.D. at Cornell, I will happily try to
find work in central New York. However, although we both love it here, part of
me expects that we will not stay after he graduates. (Good jobs for chemical
engineers do not seem to be plentiful here.) Also, part of
my decision to go to back to school for library science was that a library
degree would be useful in almost any community we moved to.
Jobs available in the area
Just as I said above. The biggest problem I see with continuing to live in this
city is that there are no job opportunities. I see more businesses closing than
I see them opening. Because of what I mentioned above, it has been 4 months now
and my fiance has been unable to find anything close to an entry level position
in his industry. There is simply no
hope or incentive to stay here.
Just not my favorite part of the country. Sorry
Just to have more into depth on how our degree can help us out in the real world
after we graduate. Also what could do to improve ourselves in the work feild.
Let us know the details for International Students Report on the Survey.
Let us know the results.
Look, everyone knows central NY is going down the tubes because people keep
moving out. Getting businesses to come to places like Consumer Square is a great
idea, but let's start a night life that involves more than drinking, dinner and
movies. Let's see some more coffee shops. Let's see Utica made cleaner and
nicer. This is not a matter of getting
people to move here so that we can have the $ to do this, this is about cleaning
up the town so that people want to live here.
lower the crime rate, improve public school programs, increase the number of
jobs available, create mandates that force rental owners to maintain their
properties, create laws that force people to pick up their trash! Bring in new
technology or some other type of job besides the industrial or manufacturing
venue. If you want educated people to stay there
has to be more than just cheap realestate. The weather sucks, the crime is high,
there is limited culture and a very undiverse population.
main reason for the area's braindrain is lack of jobs for professionals, those
with higher education. Also need to deal with hte high crime rates in Syracuse
and the general lack of non-binge-drinking night life.
Make me want to stay in this area. The weather is a prime factor for me to
leave. The infrastructure of Syracuse is poor, giving me a poor image of the
city. I need good paying jobs and a healthy work experience to outweigh the
negatives of this city.
Many of the questions in this study did not relate (and there didn't seem to be
appropriate responses for) middle aged, returning students who had a family.
Many of us don't yet know what we'll be doing after graduation. I'm far ahead of
the game and don't even have my contract arranged yet.
Maybe ROCHESTER!
maybe something about not selecting to live in central NY having to do with
economy instead of family job availability and social life
Maybe you could ask "Would you accept a lower salary if you could have very high
job satisfaction and live in a favorable location" I would. Also, added benefits
are something that I look at such as insurance and retirement as well as tuition
assistance which will be available to my children.
more art muesums
more hands on studies or experiments
More inclusive options for areas of study, hometown, desired industry, etc. The
formatting is not all inclusive as a survey should be.
More of your questions should pertain to returning adult students. There are a
lot of older students at this college, and we each have different reasons for
returning. The economy and avail. of jobs in this area aren't all that
promising. I like the area and I'm willing to get my degree in hopes of finding
stable work.
More questions about art/performance related careers
More questions about parking in downtown Syracuse.
More questions about rural/small town/urban residency preferences.
More questions about safety and style of living.
More research opportunities should be made available .
Most Colgate students are unaware of local career opportunities, and companies
who do recruit at Colgate are usually from Manhattan or Boston.
My "career" stands fairly outside the norm. I listen to what God calls me to do,
so many externals do not factor in my opinion. I am considering living in
Cornhill Utica simply because Christ came to save those neglected and unloved.
my least favorite thing about syracuse is that i need a car to live here. i
would like to be a one-car family some day, but i don't think the public
transportation system here makes that an attractive alternative
My son just graduated from college with a liberal arts degree and spent 5 months
job hunting. He wanted to stay in the area but had to take a low paying job. You
can't expect students to stay if they can't find jobs.
need more college-based information that is job-seeking related
need more intellectual stimulation
need more nightlife
needs to be some alternative questions for older students, students who are
preparing for a second career, etc.
new students need to feel "in" right away. the video will help.
New York's excessive taxes and regulations hurt business and creativity.
Next time mention the amount of time it takes to complet the questionnaire. I
didn't see it when I went through instructions, nearly quit on the way.
NO OTHER COMMENTS, THE STUDY WAS A GOOD ONE. TAUGHT NO ONE HAS INTEREST IN WHAT
STUDENTS THINK OF THIS AREA. HOPE WHOEVER PUT UP THIS STUDY GETS MORE FEEDBACK.
No, Great job putting it together, and good luck!!!!
No, it is very inclusive.
No, it seems to be good.
None - good job guys! :)
None at this time thank you
none realy except i realy need themoney
None. It's long enough. Thank you. :)
none. good luck! i took 315 last year!
none. good survey questions.
Non-traditional student questions
Non-traditional students often are already established in their community. Your
survey questions seem primarily geared toward traditional college students.
nope, thought the questions addressed a wide range of important issues
Not everyone works for someone else, and not everyone ends up working directly
out of college.
Not interested in living in rural new york
Not really anything comes to mind.
not really geared toward the non-traditional student
Not really, I just wish I could help more, but I really don't have any idea as
to what I want to do or where I want to go
not sure of what i am doing after college, not lookin to jump right into a job,
maybe peace corp, no option for someone not sure what they are doin
Nothing could keep me in the Syracuse area. In fact, I'm not even planning on
completing my degree here. As soon as my grad-student husband graduates and
figures out where he can get a job, I'm going to transfer to a school there.
Heck, he's the only reason I am here in the first place. There was a reason I
passed up SU when I was applying to
colleges for the first time (I'm working on a second bachelor's degree now). I
went to Ithaca College instead, and I am so glad I did (even if I really didn't
learn much there). Ithaca rocks, and if I were to settle anywhere in this
region, it would be there. Yay, Ithaca! Too bad it's not near anything and there
are no jobs there! That's okay! You turned
Obviously the economy is the problem, but how we build the economy is the key
issue, so any proposals would be interesting.
Offer more flexibility jobs
Offer more options for media fields
Offering jobs is priority one. All the culture in the world doesn't mean a thing
without a job. The South and West were cultural wastelands prior to the mass
movement of jobs to to those regions. There wasn't a "culture rush" to
California in 1849. Okies didn't head to California in search of hipness. Jobs
first, everything else second. Local campaigns of
coolness mistake the effects of economic success with their causes. Unless
there's some type of "creative welfare" to sustain the "creative class" until
they can become gainfully employed, no migration of creativity will ever occur.
Jobs motivate movement, not culture. I have never heard a classmate say "Golly,
that salary is great
One factor that maybe should be taken into consideration when statistically
analyzing my particular survey is that I am married and have a child. This was
the main influence for most of my responses.
One question you should ask is on a 1-10 scale how decided are people that the
central NY region has nothing to offer them after graduation. Personally I see
the SYracuse and Buffalo areas as either dead or quickly dying, or maybe just
not growing. I have lived in both places. Therefore I am inclined to leave NY
after graduation.
One thing that i think is really important for an area around a college is
transportation. As an Internatinal student(Brazil), i suffer with this issue.
Opprotunities for recruitment at school
People in this area are not that friendly to minorities. I have been often
called Oriental, or that "I am cute, and have oriental eyes"---from professors,
hairdressers, and neighbors. I feel that the area is not that open-minded about
minorities, and that as a female minority I would probably do better
(financially, career-wise, emotionally) in Los Angeles where
there is a more diverse population. There is a general feeling of economic
stagnation in the community. The pulse of the job market is not very strong, and
these are some of the reasons I would like to leave Syracuse when I graduate.
people who would have still chosen to come to the college they currently attend
if they could do it all over again
People with previous jobs in the area are more likely to stick around.
Perhaps a booklet of the ups and downs of what the area has to offer. An honest
opinion of residents and professors in the area.
Please be more inclusive with your gender question. Include transgender to the
male and female categories.
Please keep in mind that I have already been offered a job with IBM so my
opinions are based around this.
Please pay attention to the persecution of Falun Gong in China
Poor lay-out for an online survey! It's hard to follow at times- it just doesn't
read smoothly.
Possible answers as questions relate to non-traditional students that already
have family/home in this area.
Possibly clean house in Albany to better rejuvenate the region.
Potsdam is pretty rural and doesn't have much to offer students besides a few
bars.
Potsdam is very sheltered-- it's a drive just to Watertown and that's not a
place I would like to live or work either. It may sound out of place but I would
like Wegmans to come to Potsdam. By the time they do though I'll be gone.
Pretty narrow responses. Had to enter "other" alot. Seems that if you're sending
this out to alot of people, you'd at least do better research on the majors and
industries...because there are alot missing.
Professors do not tell students where to go upon graduating, especially in in
Arts and Sciences. There is nothing about graduate schools for those who want to
attend graduate schools, including the college one went as an undergrad
Providing well-knowledged and trained professors in the field.
Q27 What can the area do to better familiarize you with what it has to offer new
college graduates? Area isnt terribly specific, what area?
questions about chhosing our field of studies
questions about how much individuals believe they would make here compared to
anyother place.
Questions about what type of jobs students THINK that the community currently
offers and will it pertain to their degree of study.
quit repeating stuff
Realize that money talks, as much as everyone would like to think that our job
is a "calling" or our "dream job", reality is that if we do not get the paycheck
at the end of the week we would not show up. Reality is also that the social
system does not support working families, it is just about impossible to survive
on a single income, and with increasing costs
for healthcare and a rise in all living costs that becomes more and more true.
To keep students here, the entire area needs to be lifted up, offering decent
pay, healthcare coverage and paid vacation, so that the working class does not
slave away their entire life only to line the pockets of the top 1-2% of the
nations wealthiest.
Seems fully covered!
shorten it. i do really like the %completed listed at the top.
should take into account the density of population in the area
Show me the money
Snowmobile rentals
Solid survey
some majors have little to no use in finding jobs in this area... i'm an asian
studies major who speaks mandarin chinese and uyghur, which is spoken in central
asia... not at all close to central new york!
Some people don't want to work in CNY, regardless of what PR campaigns you can
cook up.
Something about LGBT concerns.
St. Lawrence county is supposedly the poorest county in NYS...I really doubt I'd
consider living here after graduation. If it weren't for the 4 colleges in
Canton and Potsdam, I doubt these towns would be surviving very well.
starting new businesses, or venture capital available, diversity of life styles
or cultural groups
Student's Expected Salary upon graduation (in the dream job) and comparison to
what students think is the salary they would be able to obtain doing the same
jobs in Syracuse, so that you could see if there are any misconceptions and you
can address them when you visit or send out informational catalogues.
Students getting nearing college graduation are finally starting to realize
whether or not they would like to stay near the area they are currently in,
would like to be in the area where there family is located, or would like to
completely start somewhere far away on their own. What they need at that point
and are searching for is information on different areas.
They are looking for incentive to go places and see new things, even if those
new things are right in their own area. They just need to know about it.
Study abroad options
study needs to be shorter, less listed questions. I was very tempted to end the
session.
Study seems more focused on undergraduate students. Should have a separate study
for graduate level students, issues for them differ.
Stuff about out majors.
SUNY-ESF has to project a better image of itself, most people think the school
is for "hippies" and "tree huggers" because the students already attending act
that way. A school should be defined by its programs and faculty, not the
students and their actions.
Sure, I would have liked to know the purpose, what your research inquiry is, but
I figure you are not allowed to share that.
Sweet study, good luck.
Syracuse does not offer much in the way of jobs, but in my hometown I have easy
access to a couple big cities where I could potentially work.
Syracuse has had an infestation of gang violence. This needs to be addressed
before people will want to live in this city. Students are robbed weekly. The
city needs to crack down harshly on gang related violence.
Syracuse is a dirty and dangerous town- not to mention the aweful weather. I am
not the type of person who would want to build a life here.
Syracuse is an empty city with no night life, and not enough young people. It is
too far from new york city, boston, DC, philadelphia, and it is not scenic
enough like Ithaca. I do like the place, but GOOD LUCK
Syracuse is nice but we have to do something about the job development.
Syracuse is not a bad area to live in at all. The one thing that no one can help
is the weather. In my case I grew up in this kind of weather and if Syracuse was
an area with better well-known ad agencies it would be higher on my list of
places to live when i graduate.
Syracuse is not the ideal place to settle down.
Syracuse is the "armpit of New York State". Too much crime, cloudy days, and the
public transportation sucks!
syracuse is wonderful
Syracuse just does not offer that many opportunities socially, culturally, or
job-wise that I am interested in at this time. If I didn't care about the social
and cultural aspect, I would rather live in a more rural area than a city
without these opportunities.
Syracuse might be a good place to live if: a) Jobs existed b) I didn't have to
worry about getting shot walking out to my car in the morning c) Lake Onadaga
was cleaned up In its defense it is a relatively pretty area and I like snow.
Syracuse needs some major work before it ends up a ghost town. I hope this
survey helps people realize that companies need to start coming in and not going
out. When the companies leave the people leave. I don't want to necessarily
leave but there's little opportunity here for my major and you've got to do what
you've got to do. I'll be back for the
holidays and to visit.
Syracuse needs to be more responsive to its younger population
syracuse seems like a good area to settle down and work in
Syracuse University and other schools need to take a more involved approach to
the city and make the city their own. By investing in the city, the schools will
invest in their students.
Syracuse, Utica etc. are cities that really don't offer much to students who
graduate from Colgate (unless they're from the area). Most people here are
interested in 3 job categories: banking, pre-law stuff at law firms and
politics/think tanks, so upstate doesn't really offer much to students. They'd
rather work in NYC or Boston (unless there are absolutely no
jobs available) so I don't know how relevant this whole thing is to our school.
Take into account that the university provides a much different atmosphere than
its surrounding community.
Thank You.
Thank You.
Thanks
thanks for the opportunity to fill this out
Thanks! I love central new york and would like to see more people afford/ be
able to stick around.
The 1-10 scale questions were confusing. Perhaps having the readers rate the
importance of each activity in descending order of importance. You alluded to
having done fieldwork, internships, etc. in the questionnaire. I think this is a
good idea because most students have made connections and want to return to
areas where they once worked and
lived.
The area has a general lack of technology jobs, and until this changes many of
the top students will leave upon graduation.
the average salary broken down by different careers for the central new york
area compared to cost of living and/or compared to other U.S. cities
The biggest reason I do not want to stay in Syracuse is the weather.
The choices for places to live are unrealistic. None of the ones selected fit my
choice.
The city focuses too much attention on quelling the university and subdueing the
activities of the students while not protecting them from a city that has an
ever increasing crime rate. This sours the student opinion of the city and its
level of safety when the police department is more focoused on alchohol laws
than MURDER in the city. Just last week
while my friend's house was illegally raided by police while they were not home
because people in the downstairs of a split 2 family apartment were having a
party while on the same evening in the city a double murder occured and a
student was assulted and had their wallet and cell phone stolen tells students
somthing... "You are not welcome
The cost of Utica College is very high is there any way to lower it?
The crime situation is way too bad in Syracuse to want to stay here. There are
no jobs for computer specialists here, so for people in computer industries
there are not many opportunities here.
the easiest way to keep people in the area, is to see that they multiple job
offers from local employers. people will usually go what is a safe sure thing
over the unknown. a job in the hand is better than two in the bush.
The government has to wake up and recognize the mass exodus out of this state
due to their outrageous tax policies.
The impact of New York State's taxes.
the industry questionnaire seemed kind of confusing..
The lack of a significant urban environment deters me most from living and
working in the Syracuse area. That coupled with its distance from my family, and
its unpleasant weather 70% of the year makes it a very undesirable location to
live.
The main reason I would not choose to stay in this area is because of the
winters.
the most important factor is whether one can find a job in the area
the other comments that i have is to have internacionla countries involved and
more specific majors and jobs.
The part where there was a list of possible combinations of Distance and Jobs or
whatever, was a BAD part of the study that I did NOT pay attention too and I
don't think most people ahve the patience to guess which factor was changed from
the last question, DO NOT include this type of series of questions the next time
you administer this survey.
the problem for me is that i don't have a car, so i can't go out and explore the
area whenever i want. centro provides a decent bus system, but still it doesn't
go whenever where ever, not with the convenience of owning a vehicle. my friends
and i have parties at our apartments, we visit each other, but only occasionally
do we go out for a movie or any
cultural activity in the greater area.
The purpose of this study! A variation of questions. Seems to me that you are
trying to improve the atmosphere in the Central NY area, but there was nothing
about social activities or night liefe.
The reason I don't want to live in Syracuse is because of the extremely high
crime rate within the city that makes me feel insecure with the police force and
city government. The area around Syracuse is okay, but I want no association
with the city. There is no chance of me staying in the area.
the specific result of each ethic group
The study needs a less lame title.
the study seemed fine, but I feel like my desire to venture away from home will
be interpreted as an attempt to get away from my family-who I love.
The study seemed geared towards college students who were right from high
school. The abundance of returning adult students would have helped add a whole
new dimension to this project. However, the project itself is a terrific idea,
and I hope the results are passed on to those who can make a difference in
keeping jobs and our economy strong!
Thanks!
The study seems to include a lot of areas. One more item I would include would
be if your dream job is in the area you are studying for. (Ex. I like my major
and wouldnt mind a job in it, but my dream job is totally different.)
The study should ask what students think about the area, their likes and
dislikes. For instance, the area is nice in the summer and fall. Onondaga Lake
stinks, but the other Finger Lakes are an awesome resource for outdoor
recreation. The winter is FRIGID, but this is also a great area for
snowmobiling, skiing, and snowboarding. There are several ski
resorts (although not very large) in the area.
the survey covers a lot of different areas of interest for college graduates,
making them think about what area they would prefer to live in, what type of
industry are they looking for, and what type of salary they are looking for. It
is very well organized
The survey was a bit difficult to read in terms of writing, colors, caps, etc.
Ask more questions about broader goals of people's job dreams. Most people don't
know the name of the company and/or title they want to be. Ask them questions
about where/how they can develop in the working world.
The Syracuse area does not appear to have much to offer college students. I
believe this is an incorrect assumption, yet one held more or less by myself as
well as my classmates. We are not aware of what opportunities are available in
this area, and if we were told about them, it would be infinitely helpful for
making a decision about where to live and
work after graduation.
The Syracuse area does not have a young settled adult population. As a result it
is lacking the cultural as well as the"young, hip" influences that such a
population encourages. Their is a severe lack of community in the area around
the campus and as such students are not encouraged to better the area they live
in nor are they inspired to stay here.
Syracuse's student population is the most transient i have ever experienced.
Once they have graduated, students get out of the area in a hurry. Obviously
this represents a lack on the greater Syracuse area to come up with any
convincing campaign to encourage people to stay.
The Syracuse area, despite its low cost of living and natural beauty, has very
little to offer new college graduates. There is negative economic growth, the
community is aging, and the people are tired.
The term 'immediately' used for much of the survey does no allow for local
students (those who grew up in the area and work in the area) who will be
looking to get out after a year after school. I work full-time and school
part-time, I won't begin looking to get out of here until a little bit after
graduation, but I KNOW I am moving out of NYS. This is a great
place for a well-established couple and kids, but it is very lame and lacking
for the 13 to 45 crowd. Unfortunately the best thing about CNY is you are within
a few hours of evertyhing - NYC, Adirondacks, Finger Lakes, Vermont,
Toronto/Canada...
The things that keep students from staying in CNY and Up-state NY are: The bad
weather Lack of good jobs Very limited young professional scene High crime Low
salaries (especially if you need to pay back student loans)
The weather is a huge factor in deciding what to do
The weather is also a factor. Monster.com gives information about the days of
sun each city has. Syracuse has 60 days of sun a year. The winter's have also
become very harsh in my eyes, no matter how much I enjoy winter sports. It's
depressing.
There are no jobs for me anywhere but big cities since I am a design major
There is no culture or night life in Syracuse
There really is not enough help out there to help high school kids make a
decision on what they want to do or what they would be good at.
There was no attention given to students who are married, and then those with
children.
there was no mention of any arcitectural or design major or industry and very
minor mentioning of any arts
There was really no place for me to indicate that I want to continue with
graduate school after Syracuse and so I don't really know where I will be right
after finishing school.
There were no questions about single parents attending college and what their
plans are after graduation. This survey seems to target traditonal students
rather than non-traditonal students. My college has a non-tardional student rate
of over 60%. More diversity in the questioning.
there's no hope for central new york
These responses are based on my plans now. I have 4 and a half more years here
so they could easily change.
This area does very little to keep young students here. They area politics also
don't go out and ask the students what should be done to keep us here. Upstate
NY is poverty ridden and nobody was to live in an area like this
This area isn't very attractive to prospective college graduates. Jobs are
limited, taxes are high, and the inner cities seem to be deteriorating.
This is a beautiful area and the quality of living is very good with the
exception of employment opportunities and salaries, which are extremely low.
Culturally, the area is good because of the colleges, however, a broad diversity
of options is missing and I tire of not being able to get to the theater and
symphony and varied restaurants easily.
This is a great study. I'm sorry I'm not really of any use because I'm too
young.
this is long
This region is cold, dark, and there are no national parks around here. The pay
is low, and the communities are run down. The life in upstate New York is slow
and dreamy, but the rest of the world is speeding by, offering exciting
opportunities and a rich dialogue of minds. If you demonstrate to college
students that the region can join the dialogue, they are
more likely to stay.
This study never asks if you are married or have kids, and alot of students are
and do and are nontraditional like myself.
This study seems focused on salary and career progression. While that is
important, there are many government/political issues that need to be addressed.
Consider our state's budget, college kids may not vote often, but they
understand when their TAP is delayed. There is also too much government,
outrageous taxes give the impression that we
subsidize the larger cities, and laws that make sense at the city level are
unrealistic at the state level. One word, Medicaid. Again, to the politicians
who think college kids don't vote, consider the term "voting with their feet".
this study shoild also include students's perceptions about the area of study.
This study should be more user spesific to the type of student taking it, I
myself am a 32 year old male non-traditional commuter student engaged to be
married with a one month old baby boy.
This study should be shared with the Greater Syracuse area, especially with
government officials responsible for the development of the area.
This survey, does NOT really address the "governmental" issues that are
impacting students' reasons for NOT staying in this area. Taxes are too
expensive. It is widely accepted that State Government is incompetent and
ineffective. Local leadership is NOT progressive. Furthermore, it appears that
people are NOT willing to look beyond the Northeast
to demographically similar locations that are keeping its educated populace to
see what they are doing. VERY MYOPIC worldview.
This was a great survey.
this was great, I see nothing wrong or missing
This was pretty tough, considering I've only been in college for a couple months
and haven't declared a major yet.
Those rate this area questions didn't fully apply. If there wasn't a hip young
comunity, then I wouldn't be making money. Unless there is a bunch of 40 year
skaters.
To be honest, the weather in Syracuse is not very desirable, and of course that
can't be helped. It seems though, however, that the weather affects some
people's attitudes toward each other and further solidifies the perception of
New Yorkers by other people in the country. These are two of the main reasons
why I really don't want to stay around
Syracuse. There also aren't as many jobs in the area, and let's face it, the job
market in Syracuse has been declining for over a decade.
to many questions
Too long
Too many questions assuming I am a single undergrad and what that type of person
would do after graduating. I am a PT Grad student w/ full-time job, family,
house, etc - so many questions didn't seem to make sense for me
Transportation in this area is a huge problem. It is inconsistent, and do not
come in regular intervals. It is a majoor deterent from doing things in the
community.
transportion
tv and radio
Unfortunately, the central New York area is viewed by college students as FAR
from hip and attractive. Most of the people I know look to New York, Boston and
D.C after graduation.
Unfortunately, the weather in Syracuse is horrible, which is why a lot of young
students leave the area. But the city has done nothing to promote additional
activities or a vibrant social scene for young people. For example, when trying
to think of date ideas, the only thing available in the winter time seems to be
dinner and a movie or hanging out at Armory
Square (not exactly the most exciting options).
Unlike many people, when thinking of where I'll live I'm more interested in a
place and its offerings than how close it is to my friends and family. Seems to
me many people don't chose where they live but rather default there by the
nature of job opportunities and proximity to those they know.
upstate new york bites the big one
Upstate New York doesn't HAVE any jobs for students!
Upstate NY has little to offer, it is just the way the economy works.
Upstate NY is a nice place to live and I think it would be a great atmosphere to
work and raise a family.
utica has a lot to offer but they target the wrong generation
Utica is a dull town with not much to do for the younger community. I would like
to see more hip clubs and hang out spots.
Utica is an unfriendly city and it is nearly impossible find a job anywhere near
the city
Very thorough about where one may like his/her job to be. Some others factors
such as not getting the job one would like play a huge factor in determining
where one would work and live.
very well organized...could re-word some questions
Very well put together!
weather as a factor to where i live
well done site and survey...when will the results be presented?
what about the greater syracuse area bothers you the most? the general
population, very slovenly, both in their persons and neighborhood, and the way
they drive
What are students opinions of the local area and how does this effect their
reasons for staying on campus or venturing off campus into surrounding towns and
cities.
What are your impressions of the support local government has for local
businesses large or small? Do you think businesses are moving into the area or
away from?
what does syracuse have to offer?
what is it for- the study
what is the most influential decision to stay in the area.
What kinds of places do you like to go to in this area? What kind of businesses
would you like to see move into your area?
what percentage are moving out of area/state? what fields are most promising in
central NY area?
What stops you from entering you major, ie. theater, have to audition to get
into school.
what students would like to see round the community
What the students enjoyed doing before the moved or started coming to this area.
See the differences.
Whats up.
When describing the locations, give an example of the city in question.
when people grow up in an area, some say "I'll do anything to leave this place".
So maybe a few questions about that. That is not my openion, i like the area i
live in, i just feel its to expensive and there is no job oppetunities for my
self.
where are the road signs in this area?
Where I live after school won't influence or affect my relationship with the
university.
Whoever makes up "the area" you talk about above has its work cut out for it,
between the weather and the remote location, CNY not really the most inviting
area to go out of one's way to move into. Now, if you change the weather and
bring the Yankees up here, and we might have something to talk about.
why choose the career plan to enter
WHY DID THE YANKEES LOSE, WHY!!!!!!!
why do you NOT want to study in this area?
Why do you perfer to live/not to live in this area after graduation?
why does cny want college kids to stick around
Why must choosing 'white' assume you do not want an area with a cultural
background? Maybe I'm white but would only want to live in a town with a little
italy or a chinatown. This seems to be a bit presumptuous. Just because you're
caucasian, people assume you have no culture. This is nearsighted.
Why not include weather? How do grey cloudy days influence your decision to
stay?
You could have done a better job with the structure of the questionnaire
You didn't address the cost of college and how that may affect ones choices.
you didn't consider one possibility - In my case, after I graduate, after I find
a nice job, I'll move my whole family with me to wherever my job located! I
guess not much single Americans would want to stick with their parents
forever... Well, Asians do! :)
You didn't include public sector jobs, gov. jobs.
You didn't take into account that some respondents, such as myself, are living
with parents already to offset the cost of graduate school.
You ought to include a "other/do not wish to specify" option on the "sex"
question. Although I realize that you are not asking for gender, the question is
still relatively ambiguous and somewhat misleading/confusing.
You should ask about being interested to go onto graduate school, law school, or
med school.
You should ask some questions geared to the non-traditional students (like me!)
You should ask whether or not Syracuse is a nice town, because frankly, it
sucks. Oh, and you might want to bring up the fact that Northeastern people have
an attitude problem compared with people in other regions of this country. Why
does everyone have to be so mean and arrogant?
You should make some sort of question regarding New York State's outrageous
taxes. That must play some sort of role in people's decisions on living in or
leaving New York.
you should offer "nursing" as a major because obviously you have st. joseph's
college of nursing as a college. otherwise....good study.
"young and hip" is on-line with everything else it is no longer determined
entirely by geography
Your questions are biased toward unmarried, younger students. For example,
questions about "Moving in with family". I am married for 20+ years and have two
teenage children. Living with family is non-negotiable at this time, but
answering some questions favorably would give theimpression that I am a teen or
in my young twenties myself.
Your work areas are rather broad. Maybe they should be more specific for example
(writer, producer)
| Return to "Findings" home page | Go to top of page |
Research instrument (survey design) and methods employed in this study ©2004 Vincent McCabe, Inc.